Background Color:
 
Background Pattern:
Reset
Saturday, February 16, 2019
Search
Why Is Wage Growth So Lousy?



Elliot Eisenberg, Ph.D.
GraphsandLaughs, LLC

February 1, 2019

    

While the most recent jobs report showed the unemployment rate at 4.0% — the lowest rate in almost 50 years — it also showed annual wage gains running at just 3.2%. While that is the best rate of growth in over a decade, late in the last business cycle, wage gains were over 4%, and at the height of the dot.com bubble, wage gains were over 5% a year. Shouldn’t the current tight job market result in faster wage growth as employers compete for increasingly scarce workers? The answer is “not really,” and it’s for several reasons.

The single most important reason for slow wage growth is weak labor productivity growth, or the increase in output per worker per hour. As firms pay workers more, they try to keep their profit margins up by squeezing out inefficiencies, and thus pay for the higher wages out of increased worker productivity. Back in the 1990s, labor productivity growth averaged about 3%/year. In the run-up to the housing bust, it was well over 2%. By contrast, today’s productivity growth is about 1%! As a result, employers are not so eager to raise wages as they tend to reduce profits.

Another major reason is demographics. Twenty years ago, the Baby Boomers were all in their prime working years. Today, close to 11,000/day retire and are being replaced by Millennials. The problem is that since Millennials are just starting their careers, they earn considerably less than the retiring Boomers. More importantly, the number of Millennials entering the labor force numbers about 14,000/day, exceeding by about 3,000/day, or 90,000/month, the number of retiring Boomers. While older generations have always retired as younger generations have entered the labor force, never have the two groups been of almost equal size. After accounting for this, wage growth is currently closer to 4%.

The final significant reason for slow wage growth is a lack of inflation. In the late 1990s, inflation, as measured by the CPI, was 3.5%/year, and was roughly 4%/year during the housing boom. Since 2010, however, inflation has been remarkably tame, and has hovered right around 2%. As a result, employers have not had to increase pay that much to keep up with inflation. If, for example, employers aim to increase real pay by 1%/year during the housing boom, that would have meant pay raises of 5%; today, 3% will do.

There are, of course, many other reasons why wage growth is weak. They include a decline in the strength of unions, the increased prevalence of non-compete clauses in employment contracts, and global supply chains, all of which reduce the bargaining power of workers. There has also been a steep decline in the number of new firms, in part due to the rise of super-firms like Google, Amazon and Facebook, which generally buy out any potential competitors, also reducing employer options. Last, but certainly not least, comes the dramatic rise in state licensing requirements which make it much more difficult for employees to work in other states, even if good jobs in the same field are available.

While wage growth is not as strong today as it has been in prior recoveries, there are many reasons why. Hopefully, labor productivity will improve going forward, as that is something that employers and employees both benefit from. In addition, it would be great to see states reduce or eliminate licensing requirements where possible. And, where that is not possible, encouraging reciprocity across state lines would be a great improvement.


Elliot Eisenberg, Ph.D. is President of GraphsandLaughs, LLC and can be reached at Elliot@graphsandlaughs.net. His daily 70 word economics and policy blog can be seen at www.econ70.com. You can subscribe and have the blog delivered directly to your email by visiting the website or by texting the word “BOWTIE” to 22828.

Additionally, join Realcomp at our 2019 Tools of the Trade REALTOR Expo at the Suburban Collection Showplace in Novi, MI on Thursday, May 2, 2019! Dr. Eisenberg will be providing a "live" economic update virtually and responding to questions from the audience. Don't miss it and an opportunity to have him answer one of your economy-related questions.


February 2019

February 2019

RCO3® Enhancements as of Today

RCO3® Enhancements as of Today

January Single-Family Home Sales Statistical Highlights

January Single-Family Home Sales Statistical Highlights

Why Is Wage Growth So Lousy?, by Elliot Eisenberg, President of GraphsandLaughs, LLC

February 2019 Economic Forecast by Elliot Eisenberg, President of GraphsandLaughs, LLC,

SentriLock Enhances Website to Allow for Homeowner Notifications!

SentriLock Enhances Website to Allow for Homeowner Notifications!

Upcoming DPR Webinars

Upcoming DPR Webinars

MLS Policy Improvements from November-18 Taking Effect this Week

MLS Policy Improvements from November-18 Taking Effect this Week

Access the Cheat Sheets Built Into Your SentriSmart App!

Access the Cheat Sheets Built Into Your SentriSmart App!

Webinar: Leverage Your Homes.com Account and Connect with Active Buyers

Webinar: Leverage Your Homes.com Account and Connect with Active Buyers

Interested in Learning More about LionDesk?

Interested in Learning More about LionDesk?

Last Modified: Tuesday, February 12, 2019