Gentrification is Good



Elliot Eisenberg, Ph.D.
GraphsandLaughs, LLC

October 2018

    

Over the past few decades, the term “gentrification,” i.e. high-income persons and households moving into poor minority neighborhoods, who, in doing so, push out significantly poorer lifelong residents, has become one of the most negatively loaded words in urban circles. Almost everyone has heard about a formerly inexpensive community that over a decade became very pricy and celebrated its recovery with the arrival of a Whole Foods selling overpriced kombucha and GMO-free produce.

As appealing and as plausible as this story may be, it’s an urban myth. The best empirical analyses conducted by urban economists have failed to detect a rise in displacements within gentrifying neighborhoods. This finding goes so much against conventional wisdom it seems impossible, but it’s true. As a matter of fact, researchers find that poor residents are more likely to stay put as their neighborhood improves. Moreover, the benefits of gentrification, in terms of reduced crime and better amenities, more employment opportunities, and reduced commutes are rarely, if ever, considered by naysayers.

There are three primary reasons why many believe that the poor suffer when wealthier residents move in. The first is that while all Americans move quite a bit, on average about 11.5 times during their lifetime, not everyone moves an equal amount. For example, from 2012 to 2013, 28 million Americans over age 15 moved: 11% of the population. Among households with incomes over $100,000, the percentage that moved was just 7%, compared to 13% for those with incomes below $5,000 excluding government benefits. As a result, merely observing that there are fewer poor in a neighborhood in no way suggests that gentrification is to blame.

A second explanation is that poor neighborhoods have had so little investment for so long, there is considerable slack in both their residential and commercial property markets. In most middle- and upper-class neighborhoods, virtually all housing units, store fronts and office spaces are occupied. So, the arrival of a new household or business means the departure of another. But in poorer neighborhoods there are many vacant storefronts and apartments, so much so that relatively large numbers of wealthier households can move in and not push out existing residents or businesses. One study calculated that a low-income New York City neighborhood could go from a population that is 30% poor to 12% poor over a decade without displacing anyone.

Separately, but closely related to the above, many persons who bemoan gentrification simultaneously lament racial segregation and the lack of investment in non-white neighborhoods. The introduction of wealthier residents lessens the percentage of poor persons, and that has been shown to reduce teen pregnancy and incarceration rates and other such negative outcomes. Moreover, in these communities these improved social outcomes happen through market forces and frequently absent governmental intervention. To argue against gentrification is to encourage the status quo and insist that poor neighborhoods remain poor and segregated, and needlessly cut off from opportunity.


Elliot Eisenberg, Ph.D. is President of GraphsandLaughs, LLC and can be reached at Elliot@graphsandlaughs.net. His daily 70 word economics and policy blog can be seen at www.econ70.com. You can subscribe and have the blog delivered directly to your email by visiting the website or by texting the word “BOWTIE” to 22828.


October 2018

October-2018

Audio Recording Disclosure FAQs

Audio Recording Disclosure FAQs

Gentrification is Good by Elliot Eisenberg, President of GraphsandLaughs, LLC

October 2018 Article by Elliot Eisenberg, President of GraphsandLaughs, LLC,

How Should I Plan to Learn the New Homesnap Program?

Carve out some time in your schedule, roll up your sleeves, and dig into the online Homesnap resources available to you through Realcomp’s Homesnap University for Agents webpage.

How Should I Plan to Learn the New LionDesk Program?

Visit the LionDesk Help Center and begin exploring the many online resources LionDesk has made available to users for both getting started and moving forward with learning this full-featured program!

New Photographic Alteration Policy Effective Immediately

New Photographic Alteration Policy Effective Immediately

New Product Tools Here for Realcomp REALTORS; LionDesk and Homesnap

LionDesk and Homesnap Product Tools

Realcomp Transitions to Remine as Its New Source for Public Record Data

Realcomp Transitions to Remine as Its New Source for Public Record Data

Realcomp Upgrading to a New MLS Participation and Billing System – How this May Affect You…

Realcomp Upgrading to a New MLS Participation and Billing System – How this May Affect You…

Remine Mobile

Remine Mobile is now available as an extension of your existing Realcomp MLS Subscription and access to Remine! At home or on the go, prospect better and faster with Remine.

Remine Updates

The product team at Remine have been “busy bees” and are excited about the following newer integrated features: Remine Mobile, Chat, ShowingTime and more! All features listed below were released by Remine fairly recently and may be functions you’ve been waiting for!

Showing Time Calendar

Did you know ShowingTime has its own showing calendar? Agents can see all appointments right from their ShowingTime desktop account. It's an easy way to see if your listings are getting showings. Several agents have told us they use it for gauging whether they're busy with buyers.

The “Rent Gap” Still Makes It Cheaper to Own Than Rent in These 17 Cities

Across the country, Americans are struggling with housing affordability. As home prices and interest rates continue to rise, homeownership may seem more out of reach than ever. Last year, we ran the numbers on the costs of homeownership and found that in 17 of the 33 largest metropolitan statistical areas (MSAs), owning a home was cheaper than renting.

Update your Homes.com Profile

If you have listings, then you may have leads waiting for you in your Homes.com account, provided to you at no additional cost through your Realcomp MLS Subscription. We always display the listing broker or agent and send them the listing inquiries for their properties.

Last Modified: Friday, October 5, 2018